I had the best Italian food today at lunchtime. The restaurant has such a warm and cozy atmosphere, and all the staff were incredibly friendly. The owner was in the restaurant, personally making an effort to take care of every guest. The food was absolutely delicious. I love all the beef and seafood they cooked, it’s really good! I’m traveling in Sydney and my friend is sick, but the food was so good that I even got takeaway to bring back and share with her. This was definitely one of the best memories of my trip. I really envy the people who live nearby in Sydney.

I’m really not sure of the reasons behind the good reviews. Food was below average and the atmosphere was very loud and rushed. Definitely not overly authentic Italian. Pork Belly was cold and soggy. Pizza was flavourless. Interestingly the “non” Italian food - the wedges - where exceptional. Food was not brought out together. I must give credit where deserved - we were impressed by their ability to bring out (most) dishes very quickly with prompt good service.

After trying many italian restaurants in Sydney, this one has made it to the top of our list. The food was spectacular and the service incredible as well. The ribs are the best we’ve ever had and the pastas and desserts were beautiful too. Highly recommend the lamb ragu pasta and the ricotta tiramisu.

I Maccheroni is an outstanding Italian restaurant that truly exceeded our expectations. I went with a friend and we left extremely satisfied, both with the food and the service. We started with two entrées: gnocco fritti and arancini. The gnocchi were a complete surprise — light, crispy on the outside, fluffy inside, and full of flavor. Honestly, they are among the best Italian starters I have ever had in a restaurant, if not the best. The arancini were also delicious, perfectly cooked and very tasty, setting the tone for what was to come. For the main courses, we chose the saffron mafaldine with lamb ragu and the cacio e pepe. The saffron pasta was rich and beautifully balanced with the lamb ragù, a dish that felt both hearty and refined. The cacio e pepe was prepared right at our table by a very friendly and passionate waiter, which added a special touch to the experience. Watching the dish being finished in front of us made it feel unique, and the flavor lived up to the show — creamy, peppery, and absolutely authentic. The presentation of both plates was impeccable, a real 10/10. To finish the evening, we ordered a tartufo for dessert, which was exquisite and the perfect sweet ending to the meal. We spent about $60 per person, which might seem a bit on the higher side, but for the quality of the food, the attention to detail, and the warm service, it was completely worth it. Dining here felt like a genuine Italian experience, and we walked out not only full but truly happy with the whole evening. If you’re looking for authentic, high-quality Italian food in Sydney with excellent service and atmosphere, I Maccheroni is a place I would highly recommend.

We love good Italian food & tonight didn't disappoint. My whole party loved the food, service was friendly & attentive & the wine so delicious we ordered another bottle. Second visit and we will come back. I was the only vegan in a table of four & ate handsomely with delicious bread & olives followed by a vegan pasta & vegan creme brûlée. Wonderful night!